• Home
  • Blog
  • 5 Steps to Start Your Online Reputation Management Journey

5 Steps to Start Your Online Reputation Management Journey

Blog Profile
Jason Todd
| |
online reputation management
Blog Profile
Oct 12, 2025 8 min read
Table of Contents

Every Google review, star rating, and social media comment tells a story about your business. When someone searches for your business online, the first thing they see is that mix of reviews, ratings, and maybe even a few negative comments. And what happens after that? Most people make a decision about your business in seconds, based on what they read online.

So, if your online reputation isn’t where it should be, you could be losing potential customers without even realizing it. But don’t worry; managing your online reputation isn’t as complicated as it sounds. Let’s break it down and understand how online reputation management can win over your potential customers with just a few steps.

What is Online Reputation Management (ORM) 

Online Reputation Management (ORM) involves managing your entire online presence. This includes what people see, read, and feel when they find your business online.

In simple terms:

  • ORM is about building trust online.
  • Reviews, responses, photos, and updates impact your digital credibility.
  • Consistency reflects confidence in your brand.

If you manage your online reputation well, it becomes your strongest marketing tool.

Why Reputation Management Matters for Local Businesses

For local businesses, reputation is everything. How? One strong review can bring in loyal customers, while one bad one can turn multiple potential customers away.

According to research, over 99% of consumers check online reviews before buying, and 93% say that reviews affect their purchase choices.

A strong online reputation helps you:

  • Win trust before people even visit.
  • Rank higher on Google.
  • Stand out from local competitors.
  • Keep customers coming back.

5 Steps to Start Your Online Reputation Management Journey

Now, let’s get into the practical part: how to actually get started with your online reputation management journey. 

Step 1: Audit What’s Already Out There

The first step to building or improving your reputation is to know what’s already out there. Search your business online and check how it looks to customers.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Search your business name on Google.
  • Read recent reviews, both positive and negative.
  • Check what the overall tone of the reviews is.
  • Identify if there are any repeating complaints.
  • Determine if positive reviews bring out anything specific, such as great service or exceptional quality.

This step shows you where you stand right now. You can get an idea of what customers think, what’s going well, and where you can start improving.

Step 2: Claim Your Business Profile Online

Every business should own its online presence. But what is it? When you open a physical store, you put up a sign with your business name. Right? Claiming your profile is like putting up that sign digitally.

If you don't claim it, anyone (or an automated system) can post wrong details about your business hours, address, or phone number. When you claim it, you have the password and can update everything correctly.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Start by creating your Google Business Profile.
  • After claiming your profile, complete every detail, such as your hours, contact details, website, and high-quality photos.
  • Similarly, you can create your business profiles on Yelp and Facebook.

Step 3: Ask for Reviews 

Good reviews come when you ask for them. So, what’s the best time to ask for a review? It’s right after they’ve had a positive experience.

Here’s how you can ask your customers to leave reviews:

  • Send a short “Thank You” text or email with your Google review link.
  • Add a “Review Us” QR code near your checkout counter or receipt.
  • Train your team to politely request feedback after a successful service.

Make sure that it’s effortless for your customers to share their experience. If it’s easy, they’ll likely do it.

Step 4: Respond to Every Review 

Whether and how you respond to a review matters as much as the review itself. When people see that you take time to reply, they know you care.

Here’s a simple guide:

  • For positive reviews, thank the customer and personalize your message.
  • While answering negative reviews, make sure that you stay calm. You can apologize if required and show them that you’re willing to make things right.
  • Your polite response to a negative review will show maturity and win trust from future readers.

Step 5: Track and Improve

Managing your Google reputation is not something that you can do once and forget. If you want to see great results, you need to be consistent.

Here’s what you must do:

  • View and update your business information.
  • Read and respond to reviews.
  • Tweak your strategy depending on what you learn from reviews.

These small actions will ensure that you not only get good reviews but also happy and repeat customers.

Conclusion

So, we just dived into the 5 simple steps to start your online reputation management journey. It included checking what's already there, claiming your profiles, asking for reviews, answering reviews, and improvising.

By doing these steps, you'll make your business stronger and more trustworthy. Each of these actions makes a big difference in ensuring that you own your story online. Building a strong reputation might take time, but keep in mind that every effort will surely pay off in terms of trust, visibility, and growth.

How Can TrustlyR Boost Your Online Reputation

At TrustlyR, we understand that managing online reputation can be difficult, especially when you’re extremely busy running your business. But don’t worry! We help local businesses get positive Google reviews from verified customers. 

With our services, you can:

Ready to grow your online reputation the right way? Contact TrustlyR today.

Want More Real Google Reviews?
Try TrustlyR Now!
blog thumb

Get More Google Reviews

Grow your Google Business account with real, organic Reviews using TrustlyR's proprietary influencer and email lists.

See Why TrustlyR is the TOP Google Reviews Agency

Learn More

FAQ

Yes. Most customers check reviews before choosing a local business. So managing your reputation well can increase your sales and revenue. Even small improvements in your online reputation management strategy can result in big growth.

If you’re just starting out, you can build your Google Business Profile and focus on Google reviews. They’re the most visible and influential for local searches.

No, not necessarily! You can start small by asking your customers for reviews and engaging with reviews. You can also contact TrustlyR to get more Google reviews and scale your results.

If you get an unfair review, try to stay calm. Respond professionally and briefly, apologizing that they had a poor experience and offering to solve the issue privately (via email or phone). Don't get into an argument in public.

Want to Grow Your Google Reviews?

Sign-up and see your reviews and community grow within 1 week. 

Grow Thumb